The God Contention

Is there a question to which you all would give the same - or almost the same - answer?

Printable Version

CHRISTIAN View

I certainly can't speak authoritatively for the opinion of anyone other than myself, but it seems to me that everyone can easily be convinced to agree that if something is, then it is; and also that nothing can both be and not be at the same time and in the same way. In other words, the Laws of Logic are valid.

An interesting point to note, however, is that the Laws of Logic can only be valid if Christianity is true.

Atheism must either acknowledge that infinity is not infinite, or that nothing is not nothing, making the Laws of Logic invalid under Atheism.

Polytheism insists that things that are may not be, making the Laws of Logic invalid under polytheism.

Any Monotheistic worldview without a divine atoning sacrifice insists that debts can actually be paid by one who has nothing to pay debts with, again making the Laws of Logic invalid.

Christianity alone stands coherent, allowing for the possibility of knowledge via the validity of the Laws of Logic.

Why Christianity?

Printable Version

ATHEIST View

Certainly. I'll bet we all agree spring grass is usually green and a clear sky usually blue, objects fall to the earth at approximately 32 feet per second per second, and Audrey Tautou is beautiful. Just for starters.

Audrey Tautou Fan Club

Comments

Confuzzled writes:
How can the laws of logic be both necessary and contingent as the Christian seems to imply?
Just answer the question. writes:
Everything the atheist said is true.

Everything the christian said was in avoidance of any decent answer.

'the Laws of Logic can only be valid if christianity is true.'

Brilliant. I hope for your future children's sake you are impotent.
Comment on this topic

More Questions

By what criteria do you attribute veracity to your faith's sacred text(s,) and thus the basis of that faith? Is that criteria objective?
Answers: Atheist, Christian
(25 Comments)
Given that evolution is a fact and that the evidence for it is incontrovertible, I find it very difficult to understand how religious people, mostly Christians, can deny it. Can you enlighten me?
Answers: Christian, Atheist
(69 Comments)
What is your standard of truth? How do you determine what is true?
Answers: Atheist, Christian
(114 Comments)
Did Jesus preach non-violent submission?
Answers: Atheist, Christian
(36 Comments)
Why does God require an argument to defend it, unlike something obvious like gravity for example?
Answers: Muslim, Christian
(37 Comments)