The God Contention

How is the trinity monotheistic?

Printable Version

CHRISTIAN View

Trinitarian doctrine declares the following three things:

1. There is only one God.

2. The Father is God, the Son is God, and the Holy Spirit is God.

3. These three persons are eternally distinct.

Monotheism, according to the Mirriam-Webster dictionary, is defined as "the doctrine or belief that there is but one god". As can be seen from the first plank of Trinitarian doctrine listed above, Trinitarians insist upon the fact that there is only one God, making Trinitarianism a true form of monotheism in every sense of the words.

Unitarianism, again according to the Mirriam-Webster dictionary, is the belief that "deity exists only in one person". Trinitarians are not Unitarians.

Unitarians include Muslims, Jehovah's Witnesses, Arians, and Socinians. Trinitarians consider Unitarian doctrine to be heresy -- a doctrine contrary to the truth.

The Trinity Scripturally Supported

Printable Version

MUSLIM View

Islam views the Trinity as polytheistic.

Who Invented the Trinity?

Comments

Anonymous writes:
The trinity is both polytheistic and monotheistic. In Islam, there is not this problem, because there is no god but Allah. But Christianity is incoherent because of the trinity.

Monotheism: the doctrine of belief that there is but one God.
Polytheism: belief in or worship of more than one god.

According to the first plank of the doctrine of the trinity, it is Monotheistic in every sense of the word, as Tim says. However, according to the second and third plank, the trinity is Polytheistic in every sense of the word (Father god, Son god, Holy Spirit god. Each distinct.) That is three. Three is more than one.

To accept Christianity is to accept the trinity. To accept the trinity is to accept Polytheism and Monotheism, at the same time, which is to reject Polytheism and Monotheism at the same time. To accept the trinity is to reject the trinity. To accept Christianity is to reject Christianity at the same time.
Timothy McCabe writes:
Anonymous,

If you don't mind, would you contact me directly?
http://www.godcontention.org/contact.php?id=1

Thanks!
KnowGodfromNature writes:
http://carm.org/christianity/christian-doctrine/trinity-really-teaching-there-are-three-gods
Comment on this topic

More Questions

By what criteria do you attribute veracity to your faith's sacred text(s,) and thus the basis of that faith? Is that criteria objective?
Answers: Atheist, Christian
(25 Comments)
Given that evolution is a fact and that the evidence for it is incontrovertible, I find it very difficult to understand how religious people, mostly Christians, can deny it. Can you enlighten me?
Answers: Christian, Atheist
(69 Comments)
What is your standard of truth? How do you determine what is true?
Answers: Atheist, Christian
(114 Comments)
Did Jesus preach non-violent submission?
Answers: Atheist, Christian
(36 Comments)
Why does God require an argument to defend it, unlike something obvious like gravity for example?
Answers: Muslim, Christian
(37 Comments)